情感与意向的表达是手绘的价值

The expression of emotions and intentions is the value of hand drawing

关于AI能不能代替艺术家的工作，相信有很多人争论不休。但唯一大众都信服的说法是：“AI是机器人，没有感情的，即便有也是机器类的模仿，并不能满足各种复杂条件下的情感表达的合理性。”比如，我们用AI生成多格漫画，那漫画中的人物通常都是一副呆板的笑容，AI不会区别微妙的情境和语境，进而生成适合的情绪表现。也只有人类艺术家可以对这种情况做出同理性的情感区分，通过自己娴熟的技法以及内在的表达欲驱动力画出具有张力且令人难忘的画面。

另外一个是意向的表达，比如我们设计一个logo图形，如果是AI它首先按照提示词去做要求叠加，或许我们的提示词本身就是我们的创意要求，AI可以生成带有创意的图形来，这点毋庸置疑，但是却缺少对品牌或行业内容的意向表达，什么是意向表达？通过点、线、面等元素融合来形成的图形，这种图形带有一定的感受，但这种感受不太符合行业或品牌的气质，即使它生成的图形形状看起来是对的。总之，是用感性来感知图形，而绝非单纯以理性或创意来看。

There is a lot of debate about whether AI can replace the work of artists. The only widely accepted statement is that "AI is a robot without emotions, and even if it does exist, it is a machine like imitation that cannot meet the rationality of emotional expression under various complex conditions. ”For example, when we use AI to generate multi panel comics, the characters in the comics usually have dull smiles, and AI cannot distinguish subtle situations and contexts, thus generating suitable emotional expressions. Only human artists can make empathetic emotional distinctions in this situation, using their skilled techniques and inner drive to create tense and unforgettable images.

Another aspect is the expression of intention, for example, when we design a logo graphic, if it is an AI, it will first stack the requirements according to the prompt words. Perhaps our prompt words themselves are our creative requirements, and AI can generate graphics with creativity. This is beyond doubt, but it lacks the expression of intention for brand or industry content. What is intention expression? A graphic formed by the fusion of elements such as points, lines, and surfaces, which carries a certain feeling, but this feeling is not very in line with the temperament of the industry or brand, even if the generated graphic shape looks correct. In short, it is using emotions to perceive graphics, rather than simply looking at them rationally or creatively.